Tomorrow, a federal court in Virginia will hold a hearing in a case that offers a troubling look at just how far the Trump administration will go to attack journalists and their confidential sources.
Journalist Matthew Cole is facing a Department of Justice that seems determined to force him to reveal his confidential sources. Cole was one of several journalists behind a September 2025 New York Times article about a disastrous American military operation in North Korea during the first Trump administration, one that resulted in civilian deaths.
Just five months after the article was published, the DOJ issued a grand jury subpoena to Cole, seeking to compel him to identify his sources and testify about his reporting. Cole moved to quash the subpoena, but in July, a magistrate judge recommended that his motion be denied.
If the district judge hearing the case tomorrow adopts that recommendation, it’s very possible that Cole will have to decide between burning sources and, potentially, facing crippling fines or even jail time.
The subpoena is only part of the story. The DOJ also secretly obtained Cole’s phone records in an effort to identify his sources. And it issued a sweeping legal demand to LinkedIn seeking information about Cole and other Times journalists, while ordering the company to keep the demand a secret, even from the Times itself.
Taken together, these steps show an alarming willingness by the DOJ to stop at little in its attempt to uncover confidential sources — and hint at just how much further President Donald Trump may be willing to go.
A broader campaign against journalists
In recommending the denial of Cole’s motion to quash the subpoena, the magistrate gave little weight to the broader context of the Trump administration’s attacks on press freedom. The district judge needs to correct that error.
Over and over again, the Trump administration has used government power to punish journalists and news outlets for reporting stories it doesn’t like. The list of examples is long: suing news outlets for unfavorable coverage, using the Federal Communications Commission as a cudgel against broadcasters, prosecuting journalists, barring news organizations from the Oval Office or Pentagon in retaliation for their coverage, raiding the home of a Washington Post journalist, and more.
Over and over again, the Trump administration has used government power to punish journalists and news outlets for reporting stories it doesn’t like.
The administration has also used grand jury subpoenas as a weapon against the press and its confidential sources. In one particularly telling episode, the DOJ issued subpoenas to several Times reporters, seeking to unmask the sources behind their reporting on security concerns with the airplane donated by Qatar to serve as a new Air Force One — a story that reportedly enraged Trump. The DOJ abandoned those subpoenas after a federal judge sharply criticized their efforts.
Cole’s case fits the same pattern. His reporting exposed a failed military operation and raised questions about whether the Trump administration broke the law by failing to notify Congress about it. The administration then demanded his confidential sources.
There’s yet another reason to be concerned about the government’s interest in Cole. He’s also the author of a recent book examining corruption in the Trump family’s business and political dealings, with a particular focus on Jared Kushner. Kushner and Trump are no fans of Cole’s — Kushner has claimed that the book is defamatory, while Trump dismissed it as “fake news.”
Prosecutors defending the subpoena to Cole say they were unaware of Cole’s book. That may or may not be true. But, as Cole’s motion to quash points out, it’s difficult to believe that senior-level officials who may have initiated the subpoena or signed off on it were equally unaware.
The magistrate judge discounted all of this. But given this administration’s track record, courts should be especially careful before allowing the government to use an investigation as a means of identifying and punishing journalists’ sources.
Casting an extraordinarily wide net
The sheer breadth of what the government wants from Cole is another reason to be concerned that there’s more to this subpoena than meets the eye.
According to Cole’s motion to quash, the subpoena is aimed at two years’ worth of his reporting, seeking the identities of at least two dozen sources and the substance of his conversations with them. That’s an extraordinary amount of information to demand, if the government is truly investigating a leak of classified information that appeared in a single story.
The LinkedIn demand adds to the concern that the government is more interested in digging through Cole’s sources than investigating a single leak. An appellate court recently found that the demand, which sought 18 months of data from Cole and other journalists’ accounts, was too broad, although it left open the possibility that the government could pursue a narrower request aimed at identifying Cole’s sources for the September 2025 article.
People who want to provide information to journalists about government misconduct and national security failures are far less likely to do so if the government can investigate them for embarrassing it. If the government can demand months or years of a journalist’s communications with sources in pursuit of one leak, sources are not going to trust that journalists can keep their identities confidential, and won’t come forward.
The DOJ appears to be ignoring its own rules — again
Finally, there’s reason to question whether the DOJ even followed its own internal rules before issuing a subpoena to Cole.
For years, the department has had guidelines governing subpoenas and other investigative steps targeting members of the news media. These rules are supposed to provide an important safeguard for freedom of the press. Under the Trump administration, however, they’ve been weakened, forgotten, or turned into little more than a box-checking exercise.
Cole’s case raises serious questions about whether the DOJ even followed its own internal rules, or if the attorney general is simply rubber-stamping demands for journalists’ information.
Even under the Trump administration’s weakened guidelines, before forcing a journalist to testify about confidential sources, prosecutors are supposed to exhaust other avenues of investigation. The timeline in Cole’s case raises serious questions about whether that happened.
Cole’s article ran in September 2025, and the subpoena followed just five months later. That’s an awfully short period of time in which to have exhausted other investigatory steps, like interviewing government witnesses and examining government systems. Now that it’s public that the LinkedIn case was about Cole’s reporting, it’s clear that the government has yet to obtain information from LinkedIn that it says could aid in its investigation.
The DOJ says that the attorney general personally approved the subpoena, as the guidelines require. But that doesn’t answer the more central question of whether the guidelines’ substantive requirements were followed. If anything, that response raises the more troubling possibility that the attorney general is simply rubber-stamping demands targeting journalists rather than meaningfully enforcing the protections those rules are supposed to provide.
How far will the administration go?
The stakes of tomorrow’s hearing extend far beyond one journalist or one investigation. As Cole has warned, allowing the subpoena to stand could open the door to every national security reporter and every source being subject to a government dragnet.
If that happens, many sources will simply stop talking to the press.




