This module opens by walking through examples of targeted harassment, followed by a self-doxxing activity, an activity to opt-out of a data broker service, and discussion time. Because some students may have personal experience with harassment and doxxing on the web, if this class environment feels safe enough to do so, students may share their personal experience here.
Prerequisites
Estimated time
90 minutes
Objectives
- Upon successful completion of this lesson, students will be able to identify common harassment tactics.
- Students will have the tools to identify data broker websites where their personal data is freely available, and have experience removing this data.
- Students will also have improved the privacy settings for one of their online accounts.
Why this matters
Unfortunately the need for this topic is pretty self-evident. We know newsrooms expect reporters to promote their work on the web, and in turn, face ad hoc and organized harassment campaigns. The abuse disproportionately targets self-identifying female reporters. Because this a dangerous aspect of contemporary journalism, student journalists should critically examine and mitigate against harassment and doxxing tactics.
Homework
(Before class)
- Read this, on safety considerations from April Glaser, following her reporting on Proud Boys: "13 security tips for journalists covering hate online"
- Read this, about the role of newsrooms and tech platforms in grappling with digital harassment of journalists: "News leaders and tech platforms must safeguard journalists from digital harassment to ensure press freedom"
- Read this International Women's Media Foundation report about harassment of female journalists: "Attacks and Harassment: The Impact on Female Journalists and Their Reporting"
- Read this Reporters Without Borders report on organized trolling and harassment of journalists: "Online harassment of journalists"
(After class)
- Have students try locking down their settings on one of these websites (Facebook, Instagram, Reddit) using this New York Times privacy and security resource: "Social Media Security & Privacy Checklists" — they should document which website they changed, whether they intend to keep these settings, and why. If they are on none of the above websites, they should document a lockdown procedure for the privacy settings on a different website, whether they intend to keep these settings, and why.
- (Optional) Read this paper on journalistic performativity on social media: "Personal Branding on Twitter"
Sample slides
Targeted harassment and doxxing (Google Slides)
Activities
- Watch this video introducing doxxing: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qxfSqZ62QZs
- Have students trying doxxing themselves: "A Guide to Doxxing Yourself on the Internet"
- Have students take a look at this data broker opt-out list organized by journalist Yael Grauer, and try removing themselves from just one of these services: https://github.com/yaelwrites/Big-Ass-Data-Broker-Opt-Out-List
Questions for discussion
(Following self-doxxing exercise)
- What kind of information can you find about yourself?
- How accurate or inaccurate was it?
- Did anything make you feel especially uncomfortable?
- What might someone do with this information?
- (Optional) Have you had personal experience with harassment or doxxing online? What did you have to do in response? How did that make you feel?
(Following data broker opt-out exercise)
- Before you could opt yourself out of a data broker site, what kinds of information did the service ask you for?
- How long do you think it would take you to remove yourself from all of these services?
- How long do you think it will take for your data to go back online, after it's been removed?
Related resources
- Check out our handout on preparing for harassment
- Pen America's Online Harassment Field Manual
- How to Dox Yourself on the Internet: https://open.nytimes.com/how-to-dox-yourself-on-the-internet-d2892b4c5954
- Bellingcat Verification Quizzes: "Daily Quizzes to Train Your Verification Skills"
- Freedom of the Press Foundation's list of external resources for preparing for online harassment